Linguistics 825 -- Seminar in Advanced Phonetics -- Acquistion
Spring 2005 (Call No. 11899-2 -- 05 credit hours)
Study of specific problems in articulatory and acoustic phonetics at an advanced level.
The problem addressed in Spring 2005 will be phonological acquisition --
specifically, the ontogeny of the phonological grammar
and its relationship to the changing
phonetic skills and evolving levels of
representation in the mental lexicon of the individual child
over the course of the first six years of life.
Questions that we will consider include the following:
-
Are there identifiable stages defined by appearance of different types
of phonological capabilities? If so, what does the child "know" at
these different stages of acquisition, and what does this tell us,
if anything, about the organization of phonological knowledge in the
fully competent adult speaker that the typically-developing child
eventually becomes?
-
What is the input like at different stages of acquisition and
for different phonological processes or functions?
Does the principle of "continuity" of development require that
input be the same at different stages and for different processes?
-
Also, what is the role of variability in the input?
Related to this,
when does sociolinguistic competence begin to emerge both in
realtionship to the social functions of language and in
relationship to the referential functions of language?
-
More generally, what are the constraints on acquisition?
Can we sort out universal constraints from language-specific
constraints, and if so, where do the universal constraints come from?
Back to top of page
Class Times and Locations:
Tuesdays and Thursdays, 11:30 a.m. to 1:18 p.m. in 207 Pomerene.
Instructor:
Mary E. Beckman
office: room 07 Oxley, tel 292-9752
email: mbeckman@ling.osu.edu
office hours: Wednesdays 10:00-11:00, most Fridays 2:00-3:00, & by appointment.
Coursework:
The coursework consists of three components, and the course grade
will be based on these three components as follows:
(1) 40% on the assigned group readings;
(2) 30% on three data analysis exercises;
(3) 30% on the two parts of the term project.
- Assigned group readings:
We will be reading and discussing one or two articles each
week together in class, and an essential ongoing part of the
coursework is to keep up with the readings and to contribute
to the in-class discussion. To that end, each of you
should send me a brief (three or four sentences)
review of salient points in each reading, to collate into class notes
which will be posted incrementally to the web page.
This should be done before we discuss the reading.
See the schedule of readings to
see approximately when we will be covering each reading.
(Many readings can be got online through the library's online
journal collection. For most readings, and for all readings not
available in this way, there will be a master hard copy placed in
the course mailbox in Oxley 222.
I will try to put these there at least two weeks before the first
class meeting where we discuss the topic.)
- Exercises in data analysis:
We will also be getting an appreciation of some of the primary
data types that phonologists work with when they study acquisition
by doing three transcription/tagging/acoustic-analysis exercises,
using material from the
paidologos project.
Each of these exercises will take place over a two-week period,
and typically will have an in-class introductory component and
an out-of-class "lab" component you can do in the linguistics
lab or at home on your own PC.
We will discuss these data together in class in conjunction
with the readings and ideas that we are going over during the
weeks that we do them.
Deadlines for sending me the TextGrid files and/or acoustic analyses
are on the schedule of assignments.
- Term project:
Coursework also includes the development of individual projects;
each of you will choose a more specific question of personal interest,
develop an annotated bibliography of relevant readings, and
design a study that could be done to address the chosen question.
There is a succession of interim deadlines for various
parts of the term project, listed on the schedule
of assignments. These fall into two general categories -- the choice
of topic and topic design (with three deadlines for reporting on
progress on this front), and the background reading (with two deadlines
for choosing the initial set of readings and for turning in the
annotated bibliography). Each of these categories will count of 15% of
the grade.
(Note that this schedule assumes that the study will
only be designed this quarter, and carried out at some later
time -- e.g., as part of the preparation of a 3rd Year Paper
or thesis research.
However, anyone who already has a relevant study at
a fairly detailed level of development is encouraged
to arrange with me to adapt his or her schedule
of project reports to make the completion of this study,
rather than the design, be the term project.)
Back to top of page
The following list includes both assigned readings
that everyone reads as part of the coursework and
optional readings that you can read if you are
particularly interested in the topic.
(Your bibliography also will be linked into this
part, either under the topic to which they relate,
or separately under another new topic heading if
you work on something that can't be shoehorned
into the five topic headings.)
After the introductory reading in the first week,
the readings for subsequent weeks have been divided
into sets addressing particular topics.
It is important to read the assigned readings in
each set before the first of the class meetings
where we're scheduled to discuss the topic in class,
in order to make our collated notes be a useful
starting point for discussion.
By 6:00 a.m. on the day of the first class meeting,
e-mail to me a brief synopsis (two or three sentences)
of salient points or questions for each assigned reading
that we will be covering in class.
Week 1 (class meetings March 28 & 30) --
Overview of phonological development.
- Lise Menn and Carol Stoel-Gammon (1995). Phonological development.
In Paul Fletcher and Brian MacWhinney (eds.)
The Handbook of child language, pp. 334-359. Blackwell.
- (optional) Lise Menn (2004).
Saving the baby: making sure that old data survive new theories.
In René Kager, Joe Pater, and Wim Zonneveld (eds.)
Constraints in phonological acquisition, pp. 54-72.
Cambridge University Press.
(1) Weeks 2 & 3 (class meetings April 4, 6, 11
[on which discussion of exercise 1], & 13) --
Jakobson's "strict and invariable temporal sequence"
and the challenge of "variable paths";
neo-Jakobsonian attempts to acommodate to inter-individual
variability in deterministic models of
typical and atypical phonological development.
- Marilyn May Vihman (1993a).
Variable paths to early word production. Journal of Phonetics
21, 61-82.
- Keren Rice and Peter Avery (1995).
Variability in a deterministic model of language acquisition: A
theory of segemntal elaboration. In John Archibald (ed.)
Phonological acquisition and phonological theory, pp. 23-42.
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
- Daniel A. Dinnsen and Steven B. Chin (1993). Individual differences
in phonological disorders and implications for a theory of acquisition.
In Fred R. Eckman (ed.) Confluence: Linguistics, L2 acquisition,
and speech pathology, pp. 138-152. John Benjamins.
- (optional) Marilyn Vihman and Shelley Velleman (2000). Phonetics
and the origins of phonology. In Noel Burton-Roberts, Philip Carr,
and Gerard Docherty (eds.) Phonological knowledge: Conceptual and
empirical issues, pp. 305-339. Oxford University Press.
(2) Week 4 (class meetings April 18 & 20) --
Understanding the extent of variability within a child: the
phenomenon of covert contrast.
- Shari R. Baum and James C. McNutt (1990).
An acoustic analysis of frontal misarticulation of /s/ in children.
Journal of Phonetics, 18, 51-63.
- James M. Scobbie, Fiona Gibbon, William J. Hardcastle, and
Paul Fletcher (2000). Covert contrast as a stage in the acquisition
of phonetics and phonology. In Michael B. Broe and Janet Pierrehumbert
(eds.) Papers in laboratory phonology V: Acquisition and the lexicon,
pp. 194-207. (Cambridge University Press.)
- (optional) Thomas Berg (1995). Sound change in child language:
a study of inter-word variation. Language and Speech 38, 331-363.
- Jan Edwards, Fiona Gibbon, and Marios Fourakis (1997). On discrete
changes in the acquisition of the alveolar/velar stop consonant contrast.
Language and Speech 40, 203-210.
(3) Weeks 5 & 6 (class meetings April 25
[on which discussion of exercise 2] & 27, May 2 & 4) --
Word learning and the nature of input representations.
- Joe Pater, Christine Stager, and Janet Werker (2004).
The perceptual acquisition of phonological contrasts.
Language 80, 384-402.
- Carol Stoel-Gammon (1998). Sounds and words in early language
acquisition: the relationship between lexical and phonological
development. In Rhea Paul (ed.) Exploring the speech-language
connection, pp. 25-52. Paul H. Brooks Publishing Co.
- Mary E. Beckman and Jan Edwards (2000). Lexical frequency effects
on young children's imitative productions.
In Michael B. Broe and Janet Pierrehumbert (eds.), pp. 208-209.
- Jan Edwards (2000). Commentary: Lexical representations in acquisition.
In Michael B. Broe and Janet Pierrehumbert (eds.), pp. 240-249.
- (optional) Lise Menn and Edward H. Matthei (1992).
The 'two-lexicon' model of child phonology: looking back, looking ahead.
In Charles A. Ferguson, Lise Menn, Carol Stoel-Gammon (eds.)
Phonological development : models, research, implications,
pp. 211-247.
- (optional) Bruce Hayes (2004).
Phonological acquisition in Optimality Theory: the early stages.
In René Kager, Joe Pater, and Wim Zonneveld (eds.), pp. 158-203.
(4) Week 7 (class meetings May 9 [discussion of exercise 3] &
11 [presentations of project topics]) --
Maturational effects and the relationship to input.
- Patricia K. Kuhl and Andrew N. Meltzoff (1996). Infant vocalizations
in response to speech: Vocal imitation and developmental change.
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 100, 425-2438.
- Florien J. Koopmans-van Beinum, Chris J. Clement,
and Ineke van den Dikkenberg-Pot (2001).
Babbling and the lack of auditory speech
perception: a matter of coordination? Developmental Science
4, 61-70.
- (optional) Marilyn May Vihman (1993b).
Vocal Motor Schemes, Variation and the Production-Perception Link.
Journal of Phonetics 21, 163-69
- (optional) Lucie Ménard, Jean-Luc Schwartz, and Louis-Jean Boë
(2004). Role of vocal tract morphology in speech development:
Perceptual targets
and sensorimotor maps for synthesized French vowels from birth to
adulthood.
Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 47, 1059-1080.
- (optional) Feng-Ming Tsao, Huei-Mei Liu, and Patricia Kuhl (2004).
Speech perception in infancy predicts language development in the
second year of life: A longitudinal study.
Child Development 75, 1067-1084.
(5) Weeks 8 & 9 (class meetings May 16, 18, 23, & 25 [5-min
presentations of project design]) --
The function and nature of the input at two stages of development.
- Hanus Papousek, Mechtild Papousek, and David Symmes (1991).
The meanings of melodies in motherese in tone and stress languages.
Infant Behavior and Development 14, 415-440.
- Paul Foulkes, Gerard Docherty, and Dominic Watt (2005).
Phonological variation in child-directed speech. Language
80, 177-206.
- (optional) Julie Roberts (2002) Child language variation.
In J.K. Chambers, Peter Trudgill, and Natalie Schilling-Estes (eds.)
The handbook of language variation and change, pp. 333-348.
Blackwell.
Week 10 (class meeting June 1)
No readings -- 15 minute class presentations.
Back to top of page
This part will be filled in as the course progresses.
Back to top of page
- Transcription exercise 1 (fricatives): TextGrids due by April 8,
for me to collate and for us to discuss in class on April 11.
wav files
- Transcription exercise 2 (plosives): TextGrids and summary of
VOT values due by April 22, for me to collate and for us to discuss
in class on April 25.
wav files
- Transcription exercise 3 (vowels): TextGrids showing
transcription notes and measurement points, and summary
of methods due by May 16, for me to collate and for us to
discuss in class on May 18.
wav files
-
Project topic: By May 11, choose a topic and discuss the topic
choice with me. Start putting together a bibliography
of five or so articles relevant to the topic. Be prepared to
describe the topic to the class on May 11, to invite comments
and feedback, including suggestions for additions to your bibliography.
-
Project bibliography: By May 25, turn in an annotated bibliography
in pdf format or in plain ASCII, suitable for posting on the class
web page.
-
Initial research design:
Also by May 25, on the basis of your background
literature review, devise a study that would address
the topic that you have chosen.
Be prepared to make a short (no more than 5 min) presentation
to the class, in which you describe the initial research design,
relating it to the readings, and invite suggestions and feedback.
-
Final research design:
On June 1, be prepared to present your refined research design,
perhaps with some examples or the like, to the class in no more
than 15 minutes. The handout or slides of your presentation will
be your final project report.
Back to top of page
More links will be added here as the course progresses and
we discover other web resources that are potentially relevant
to the questions we are addressing as a group
and/or in our individual term projects.
-
Click here for the CHILDES
home page.
-
Click here to see the home page for the
paidologos project.
-
Click here to see charts of
WorldBet symbols
for the transcription exercises and here to see Kathleen's
notes
on tips for transcribing in praat.
Back to top of page
Address comments and queries about this page to:
mbeckman@ling.osu.edu